Skip to main content

What are the Financial Advantages of Choosing OPNsense over pfSense?

Published on:
.
7 min read
.
For German Version

In today's rapidly evolving digital landscape, safeguarding networks against cyber threats has become a major concern for organizations of all sizes. Firewalls stand as the first line of defense, tasked with fortifying networks and protecting sensitive data from malicious intrusions. Among the array of firewall solutions available, two notable contenders, OPNsense® and pfSense® software, have emerged as leading choices for businesses seeking robust cybersecurity measures.

OPNsense® and pfSense® software are open-source firewall platforms renowned for their versatility, reliability, and comprehensive security features. Developed to meet the diverse needs of modern organizations, both platforms offer a range of functionalities, including packet filtering, VPN support, traffic shaping, and intrusion detection systems (IDS).

While both OPNsense and pfSense share similarities in terms of features and capabilities, they differ significantly in their pricing structures. These disparities stem from various factors, such as licensing models, subscription options, and additional services offered by each platform. Understanding these cost differences is essential for organizations as they evaluate the most cost-effective solution tailored to their specific requirements.

This article delves into an in-depth comparison of their pricing models and explores each system's financial advantages.

Migrating from pfSense to OPNsense can involve several cost-related factors, including both potential savings and potential expenses. Some benefits of migrating from pfSense to OPNsense are given below:

  • Licensing: OPNsense being entirely open-source eliminates licensing costs compared to pfSense's potential expenses for its Enterprise edition.
  • Hardware: OPNsense's lower resource requirements might allow you to run it on existing hardware or less powerful hardware compared to pfSense software, potentially saving on hardware acquisition or upgrade costs.

How Does the Pricing Structure of OPNsense Compare to That of pfSense?​

Unlike pfSense, which offers both CE and paid subscription models, OPNsense takes a completely open-source approach. This means there are no direct licensing fees associated with using OPNsense. However, it's important to consider that both solutions require investment in hardware to run on. While the lack of licensing fees makes OPNsense initially cost-effective, the reliance on community support instead of paid technical support offered by pfSense could impact the long-term cost depending on your organization's technical expertise and comfort level with self-reliance.

pfSense pricing structure is summarized as follows:

  • Netgate Appliance: pfSense Plus software is included at no extra charge when purchasing a Netgate appliance. These turnkey appliances start at $189, offering various options for memory, storage, TAC support, and extended warranty.
  • Cloud: pfSense Plus is available on Amazon and Azure marketplaces, offering virtual machine options with different configurations. Prices range from $0.01/hr to $0.40/hr, with free 30-day software trials available.
  • Software: For existing users, pfSense Plus software can be obtained by migrating from a pre-installed pfSense CE image. The annual subscription for pfSense Plus software starts at $129/year.

OPNsense pricing structure is summarized as follows:

  • OPNsense® Business Edition (3-Year Subscription): Originally priced at Euro447, now on sale for Euro359. This subscription provides access to the OPNsense Business Edition for three years.
  • OPNsense® Business Edition (1-Year Subscription): Priced at Euro149 per year, this subscription grants access to the OPNsense Business Edition for one year.
  • OPNsense® on Amazon AWS EC2 and Azure: Pricing information not provided. OPNsense is available on Amazon AWS EC2 and Azure cloud platforms.
  • ETPRO Telemetry Edition: Available for free, this option provides access to ETPRO Telemetry edition.
  • Proofpoint ET Pro Ruleset (1-Year Subscription): Priced at Euro749 per year, this subscription offers access to the Proofpoint ET Pro Ruleset for one year.
  • Zenarmor NGFW plugin: The free version is available. For 100 devices, it starts from $9.90 for a monthly subscription

What Cost Factors Are Involved in the Pricing of pfSense and OPNsense?​

Although pfSense and OPNsense both have powerful firewall features, the two have very different pricing models. Even though pfSense and OPNsense are open-source firewall/routing solutions built on FreeBSD, there are a few hidden costs to consider when deploying and managing them. What follows is a breakdown of some of the costs that went into determining the prices of the two items.

  1. Hardware Costs: Both platforms are versatile and can be used on a wide range of hardware, from inexpensive embedded systems to robust enterprise servers, but their prices differ. Things like performance requirements, redundancy, and scalability determine the cost.
  2. Support Subscriptions: For more involved deployments, you can pay for a subscription to commercial support that covers setup, configuration, troubleshooting, and maintenance. The level of support, the number of devices/licenses, and the length of the subscription determine costs.
  3. Training and Professional Services: Organizations should consider investing in staff expertise or seeking external help to ensure the effective use and management of these platforms. Further assistance with deployment, customization, and optimization can be provided by consultants or service providers, who can add to the cost. Installing pfSense, especially on non-Netgate hardware, might require a certain level of technical knowledge and comfort working with operating systems and networking configurations. If you're not familiar with these processes, consider seeking assistance from someone with experience or exploring managed pfSense solutions from Netgate or other providers.
  4. Additional Modules and Add-ons: You may have to shell out some cash for some premium features, even though the app's core functionality is free. These provide services such as VPNs, content filtering, intrusion detection systems, and antivirus software.
  5. Licensing and Compliance: Organizations should think about the features and technologies in pfSense or OPNsense, as well as the licensing requirements and compliance costs, based on the use case and industry regulations.
  6. Infrastructure Costs: To ensure high availability and reliability, deployments may necessitate supplementary infrastructure such as networking gear, redundant power sources, and data center facilities.
  7. Operational Costs: Salaries of staff, power, cooling, and other overhead costs are part of the ongoing expenses for managing and maintaining pfSense or OPNsense deployments.
  8. Integration and Compatibility: It may be necessary to put in some extra time and money to test and ensure everything works together when you install pfSense/OPNsense in your IT environment.

The software is free, but there are other costs that organizations need to think about when calculating the total cost of ownership (TCO) of pfSense or OPNsense for their particular setup. A comprehensive TCO analysis helps organizations make informed decisions when choosing and implementing these open-source firewall solutions.

Are There Any Licensing or Subscription Costs Associated with OPNsense?​

No, OPNsense itself does not have any licensing or subscription costs. OPNsense is an open-source solution and does not require a license to use. However, there are subscription options available for support and additional features. The Business Support Subscription is an annual subscription that provides remote support by email and phone, implementation support, predefined configurations, migration assistance, troubleshooting, and hotfixes.

How Do These License and Subscription Costs Differ from pfSense?​

In comparing the subscription and license costs of OPNsense with pfSense, the following can be summarized:

  • Completely Free and Open-Source: OPNsense provides a wider range of features compared to pfSense's free Community Edition, including advanced firewall functionalities, multi-WAN failover, basic VPN capabilities, and various add-ons available through the OPNsense repository.
  • Optional Deciso OPNsense Support Subscriptions: These do not provide access to additional features like pfSense's Enterprise Edition. Instead, they focus solely on enhanced support for a subscription fee. This includes:
  • Priority support channels: Faster response times and access to dedicated support personnel.
  • Technical assistance: Additional support beyond the community forum, potentially including troubleshooting assistance and configuration guidance.

OPNsense offers a wider range of features in its free version compared to pfSense's Community Edition. pfSense's subscriptions unlock additional features, while OPNsense's subscriptions solely focus on enhanced support, not feature access.

Can Organizations Save on Hardware and Infrastructure Costs When Choosing OPNsense as Their Firewall Solution Over pfSense?​

Yes, choosing OPNsense over pfSense can potentially save organizations on hardware and infrastructure costs, but it's not a guaranteed outcome. The majot factors influencing potential hardware and infrastructure savings of deploying OPNsense instead of pfSense are listed below:

  • Lower Minimum Requirements: OPNsense has slightly lower minimum hardware requirements compared to pfSense, requiring only 512 MB RAM compared to pfSense's 1 GB minimum. This could allow organizations to run OPNsense on older or less powerful hardware they already own, delaying or eliminating hardware upgrades.
  • Efficient Resource Usage: OPNsense is generally known for being less resource-intensive compared to pfSense. This means it might require less powerful hardware to run efficiently, especially for smaller networks. This could potentially translate to lower hardware acquisition costs.

Simple home or small office networks might not see significant resource differences between pfSense and OPNsense. The potential for hardware cost savings becomes more relevant for larger networks with heavier traffic or requiring more complex functionalities. Regardless of platform, the specific hardware requirements for your network will ultimately depend on factors like the number of devices, internet bandwidth, and features used. The most significant cost savings come from utilizing existing hardware capable of running OPNsense. Organizations with suitable existing hardware might avoid hardware upgrade costs entirely.

While OPNsense holds potential for hardware and infrastructure cost savings, it's crucial to carefully evaluate your specific needs, existing infrastructure, and technical expertise before making a decision.

What is the Long-Term Cost-Effectiveness of OPNsense in Terms of Maintenance and Support Compared to pfSense?​

When comparing the long-term cost-effectiveness of OPNsense and pfSense in terms of maintenance and support, several factors come into play. OPNsense, being open-source, eliminates licensing fees, offering a cost advantage from the outset. However, while it provides free community support forums and resources, organizations may need to invest in additional resources for in-house maintenance and troubleshooting, potentially incurring costs in terms of time and expertise.

On the other hand, pfSense offers CE edition and paid subscription models, with varying levels of support that come with associated costs. Renewal fees for pfSense subscriptions need to be considered for long-term budget planning. Additionally, the choice between self-reliance with OPNsense and having access to dedicated support with pfSense impacts the overall cost equation, as does the skill level required for managing and troubleshooting each platform. While OPNsense offers a lower initial financial outlay, its cost-effectiveness over time depends on factors such as ongoing support needs, staff training, and the organization's preference for self-reliance versus dedicated support. Therefore, making an informed decision requires a thorough assessment of these factors per the organization's specific requirements and resources.

Are There Specific Use Cases or Scenarios Where the Financial Advantages of OPNsense Become Particularly Evident in Contrast to pfSense?​

Yes, there are some potential use cases where OPNsense's cost-effective advantages over pfSense become apparent:

  • Cost-Conscious Organizations: For businesses operating on limited budgets that prioritize open-source solutions, OPNsense's lack of licensing fees and reliance on free community support can significantly reduce upfront and ongoing costs, making it an attractive option.
  • Organizations with In-House IT Expertise: If an organization boasts a team of IT professionals with the necessary technical proficiency to manage and troubleshoot network security solutions independently, OPNsense's absence of direct support costs becomes a notable advantage, minimizing the need for external assistance and associated expenses.
  • Smaller Deployments: In scenarios where security requirements are relatively straightforward and the network deployment is modest in scale, the free version of pfSense or OPNsense may suffice. In such cases, opting for OPNsense eliminates licensing fees, potentially resulting in greater cost savings over time.
  • Organizations Comfortable with Community Support: Businesses that are comfortable relying on community forums and resources for support rather than investing in dedicated paid support services may find OPNsense to be a more cost-effective solution. By leveraging the expertise of the open-source community, organizations can address issues and challenges without incurring additional expenses.
  • Long-Term Cost Considerations: For organizations prioritizing long-term cost control and minimizing ongoing ownership expenses, OPNsense's open-source nature presents a compelling proposition. Unlike pfSense's subscription model with recurring renewal fees, OPNsense offers a pathway to lower overall costs, particularly for those willing to invest in internal expertise and self-sufficiency.

It's essential to note that while these scenarios highlight OPNsense's cost-effective advantages, the optimal choice ultimately depends on each organization's unique circumstances and priorities. Evaluating factors such as budgetary constraints, technical capabilities, and long-term strategic objectives will guide the decision-making process effectively.

What Are the Potential Indirect Cost Savings Associated with OPNsense, Such as Improved Security and Reduced Downtime?​

While the initial cost of a solution like OPNsense might be lower compared to some proprietary firewalls, the true value lies in its potential for indirect cost savings across various aspects of your organization's operations. Some key areas where OPNsense contributes to significant cost reductions are outlined below:

1. Improved Security​

Enhanced security measures can mitigate the risk of data breaches and cyberattacks, resulting in potential cost savings associated with avoiding lost revenue, legal fees, and reputational damage.

2. Reduced Downtime​

Minimized network disruptions and downtime due to improved stability and reliability can lead to cost savings by avoiding productivity losses, service interruptions, and emergency IT support expenses.

3. Streamlined Management​

Simplified network management and administration reduce the time and resources required for system maintenance, troubleshooting, and configuration changes, resulting in operational cost savings.

4. Compliance and Data Protection​

Compliance with regulatory requirements and data protection standards prevent non-compliance penalties, fines, and legal fees, contributing to overall cost savings and risk mitigation.

5. Optimized Network Performance​

Improved network performance and efficiency enhance productivity and user experience while reducing bandwidth congestion and resource wastage, leading to potential cost savings in operational efficiency.

6. Software Updates and Patch Management​

Efficient software updates and patch management processes minimize security vulnerabilities and the risk of exploitation, reducing the likelihood of costly security incidents and remediation efforts.

7. User Productivity​

A secure and reliable network infrastructure boost user productivity by minimizing disruptions and downtime, resulting in indirect cost savings through increased efficiency and output.

8. Business Continuity​

Proactive measures for disaster recovery and business continuity planning mitigate the financial impact of potential disruptions, ensuring uninterrupted operations and safeguarding against revenue losses.

9. Resource Allocation​

Optimal resource allocation and utilization facilitated by OPNsense streamline IT operations, improve resource efficiency, and reduce unnecessary expenses, contributing to overall cost savings.

10. Enhanced Scalability​

Scalability features of OPNsense enable organizations to adapt to changing business needs and accommodate growth without incurring significant infrastructure costs, supporting long-term cost-effectiveness and flexibility.

How Does the Availability of Community Support and Open-Source Resources Impact the Financial Considerations When Making the Switch to OPNsense?​

When contemplating a switch to OPNsense, the consideration of community support and open-source resources alongside cost savings is paramount. While the potential for financial benefits is evident, the availability of community support and open-source resources significantly influences the financial aspects of this decision. OPNsense relies on a robust community of users and developers who actively contribute to support through various channels such as forums, documentation, and online communities. Unlike paid support options offered by many vendors, this community support is freely accessible, providing users with valuable assistance without additional costs. While community support offers numerous benefits, it's essential to acknowledge its potential limitations. Delays in receiving responses, varying expertise levels within the community, and the necessity for self-reliance are factors organizations should consider. However, organizations with proficient in-house IT expertise may effectively leverage community support to troubleshoot issues independently, mitigating potential limitations.

The financial impact of community support and open-source resources should not be overlooked when evaluating the switch to OPNsense. The value of community support depends on individual needs and resources, and organizations are encouraged to assess their comfort level with self-reliance and technical expertise. By considering these factors alongside cost savings, organizations can make well-informed decisions regarding the adoption of OPNsense.

Are There Case Studies or Real-World Examples Demonstrating the Financial Benefits of Transitioning from pfSense to OPNsense?​

Finding readily available case studies specifically comparing the financial benefits of switching from pfSense to OPNsense might be challenging duw to the following reasons:

  • Open-source nature: Due to the open-source nature of OPNsense, deployments are often not documented or publicized as extensively as commercial solutions.
  • Focus on security: Organizations that transition to OPNsense might prioritize the enhanced security features and open-source philosophy over purely financial considerations. Making a direct cost comparison challenging.
  • Indirect cost savings: The financial benefits of OPNsense can lie in indirect cost savings like reduced downtime, improved productivity, and less reliance on paid support. These benefits can be harder to quantify and generalize across different organizations.

However, here are some alternative approaches that might be helpful. You may find some case studies demonstrating the financial benefits of transitioning from pfSense to OPNsense by following the next steps:

  1. Searching community resources: Search online forums and communities dedicated to OPNsense. Users often share their experiences, including success stories and cost-saving benefits they've achieved by switching from pfSense.
  2. Searching cost-benefit analysis examples: Look for case studies or white papers that analyze the cost-benefit of open-source firewalls in general. While they might not directly compare pfSense and OPNsense, they can provide valuable insights into potential financial advantages.
  3. Searching total cost of ownership (TCO) calculators: Some open-source firewall vendors offer TCO calculators on their websites. These tools help estimate the total cost of ownership, including hardware, licensing, and support, for a specific network setup. While not specific to pfSense vs. OPNsense, they can be a valuable starting point for understanding potential cost differences.

Remember, the best approach to evaluating the financial benefits of switching to OPNsense is to consider your specific needs and resources. Analyze your current pfSense setup, including licensing costs and support needs. Then, factor in your in-house IT expertise and comfort level by leveraging community support. This will allow you to make a more informed decision regarding the potential cost benefits of transitioning to OPNsense.

Last updated on by Zenarmor